next up previous
Next: OB subdwarfs Up: Spectroscopic techniques Previous: Spectroscopic techniques

OB dwarfs and supergiants

The majority of detailed analyses of OB stars have been subject to the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium in a plane-parallel atmosphere (e.g. Herrero et al. 1992; Puls et al. 1996). However, should stellar winds be strong, absorption lines will be contaminated by wind effects (Schaerer & Schmutz 1994; Crowther & Bohannan 1997). Optical HeI-II lines generally provide temperature diagnostics for O stars (e.g. Herrero et al. 1992) while SiII-IV lines are used for B stars (e.g. Becker & Butler 1990), though Kudritzki (1992) discussed the complicating role of velocity fields for investigating supergiants. Kilian et al. (1991) employed both He and Si diagnostics for early B dwarfs and giants which agreed relatively well, though with differences of up to 1800K. Kilian et al. (1991) and Grigsby et al. (1992) used line blanketed atmospheres to obtain effective temperatures systematically higher (2000K) than those from -- photometric calibrations (e.g. Lester et al. 1986). The scale for B supergiants has been improved upon recently by McErlean et al. (1997) who used SiIII-IV diagnostics for early-types, with non-LTE corrections to results from the Lester et al. (1986) calibration applied to mid/late B supergiants.

Recent ionization equilibrium techniques for O stars represent considerable advances relative to earlier (insensitive) continuum methods. For example, Bohannan et al. (1986) obtained =42kK from a non-LTE wind blanketed analysis of Pup (O4I(n)f), with =32--50kK obtained from continuum techniques. However, widely varying results have also been found in recent non-LTE spectroscopic analyses of late O/early B dwarfs. For instance, for HD214680 (10Lac, O9V) Grigsby et al. (1992) derived =30.0kK using a line-blanketed model atmosphere, in sharp contrast to =37.5kK from the unblanketed analysis of Herrero et al. (1992). Despite these conflicting results, HD214680 remains widely used as a standard in --photometric calibrations following Malagnini et al. (1986) who used LTE Kurucz continuum fits to obtain =31.75kK. Studies based on similar non-LTE models can result in discrepant temperatures when based on optical or UV diagnostics (e.g. Melnick 42, Heap et al. 1991, Pauldrach et al. 1994). Indeed, within a single analysis different diagnostic line ratios often yield considerably different temperatures -- for HD46150 (O5V(f)), Herrero et al. (1992) obtained =42.5kK from HeI 4922/HeII 4542 compared with =47kK from HeI 4471/HeII 4542.

Detacted OB binaries provide useful tests of spectroscopic analyses since their masses, radii, gravities can be independently and accurately determined, though temperature determinations generally rely on Strömgren photometric calibrations (Schönberner & Harmanec 1995; Hilditch et al. 1996) which are imprecise for O and early B stars.

  
Figure 3: Comparison of our revised temperature scale for OB stars (PAC, thick solid line), available in tabular form on request, with the standard calibrations of Böhm-Vitense (1981) and Schmidt-Kaler (1982), plus the recent linear O star scale of Vacca et al. (1996)

Various MK spectral type-- correlations have been attempted for OB stars over the past couple of decades, including Böhm-Vitense (1981), Schmidt-Kaler (1982) and Humphreys & McElroy (1984). While these remain widely used, in ionizing flux calibrations for instance (necessary for photoionization studies of HII regions and starbursts), more recent scales have been obtained by Howarth & Prinja (1989), Theodossiou & Danezis (1991) and Vacca et al. (1996) using more recent observational and theoretical results. Due to the plethora of new results in this field we present a revised scale of OB dwarfs and supergiants in Fig. 3, based on results from various direct, continuum and ionization equilibrium techniques. Previous standard scales are also included -- note that we find considerable differences relative to the recent Vacca et al. (1996) calibration for O dwarfs since we incorporate results from blanketed studies (e.g. Voels et al. 1989; Grigsby et al. 1992) and do not impose a linear scale.



next up previous
Next: OB subdwarfs Up: Spectroscopic techniques Previous: Spectroscopic techniques



Paul Crowther
Wed Sep 23 13:41:03 BST 1998